Eating Great Pizza In Saint Augustine

Explore Old City brings you the best pizza restaurants in all of Saint Augustine.

Saint Augustine is blessed to have an abundance of really good pizza restaurants

I am a firm believer that the best pizza comes from up North in states like New Jersey, New York and Connecticut. So it’s really great that a lot of those pizza people have decided to throw off winter and move South! Many of them have chosen to set up shop in right here in Saint Augustine. Any of the pizza shops listed here have the EOC Seal of Approval, so dig in and mangia!

Pizza Time: No-frills stop-in pizzeria boasting a wide selection of New York-style pies by the slice. It got a review that went viral and there can sometimes be a wait to get in the door. Is it “the second best pizza in America”? Stop in and decide for yourself!

124 St George Street, St Augustine, FL 32084

Pizzalley’s on St. George: Known for pasta salad, this Italian joint also offers other familiar dishes such as lasagna & pizza. Stop by any day of the week and get a free sample of their pizza. This is the one place on this list I have yet to try.

117 St George Street, St Augustine, FL 32084
Visit their website

Carmelo’s Marketplace: Quaint Italian eatery known for hearty pies, salads & other comfort-food favorites among warm decor. I have eaten here many times, and it’s very good. My son Calvin loves their wings.

146 King St, St Augustine, FL 32084
Visit their website


Al’S PizzaCasual pizzeria chain serving up pies, calzones, subs & pasta in a contemporary space. Yes, it’s a pizza chain, and yes it’s good. Great atmosphere and it’s at the very start of Saint George street to the north.

1 St George St, St Augustine, FL
Visit their website


Borrillo’s Pizza & Subs: Tiny, no-frills pizzeria & sandwich shop serving NY-style brick-oven pies, plus cheesesteaks & more. Very good pizza with extra parking around the back.

88 San Marco Ave, St Augustine, FL 32084
Visit their website


St. Augustine Mellow Mushroom Pizza: Funky, art-filled chain pizzeria featuring craft beer, calzones & creative stone-baked pizzas. Mellow Mushroom is known for their artisan bread pizza crust…delicious!

410 Anastasia Blvd, St Augustine, FL 32080
Visit their website

New York Pizza Company in Palencia: Unassuming locale turning out made-to-order pies & pasta dishes with custom mix-ins. As their name implies, they are New York style pizza. As I write this I am eating their meatball, green pepper and pepperoni personal pie with crispy crust. Outstanding.

163 Palencia Village Dr, St Augustine, FL 32095
Visit their website


Puccini’s Pizzeria: Local Italian chain serving specialty pizzas, pastas & sandwiches in a casual, stylish space. It’s right across the street from beautiful Vilano beach. Live music on weekends.

85 Ava Way, St Augustine, FL 32084
Visit their website

A Brief History Of Where Pizza Actually Came From

Really interesting video about the history of pizza, and guaranteed to make you hungry enough to make you order one before the video ends. Just sayin’…

No Comment

Leave a Reply